Outdoor Fire Pit vs. Fireplace – 6 Things to Consider

by | Landscape Design

Landscaping Sacramento: Sacramento Landscape Design wtih retaining wall steps creating a beautiful outdoor living space.

Outdoor Fire Pit vs. Fireplace: 6 Things to Think About

Outdoor Fireplace vs Outdoor Fire Pit: Which One is Right for You?

Custom Outdoor Fire Pit

Can’t decide between an outdoor fireplace and a fire pit? Choosing the right one can make your outdoor living space far more enjoyable, whether hosting a get-together or a romantic night under the stars. There are so many things to consider it can be hard to decide.

This blog post will discuss six mportant things to consider when selecting between an outdoor fire pit and a fireplace. We’ll look at the main differences between the two choices, talk about the pros and cons of each, and give you tips on choosing the best one for your needs and tastes.

We’ll talk about everything you need to know to make an informed choice, from the atmosphere to the warmth they create. By the end of this article, you’ll determine which choice is best for your outdoor space and the experience you want to have. So, let’s start and find the best backyard fire pit for you!

Which Is Better, an Outdoor Fireplace or a Fire Pit?

Custom landscaping outdoor fire place installation

outdoor fireplace installation

Choosing between an outdoor fireplace and a fire pit can significantly affect how warm and inviting the space feels throughout the year. Both choices will keep you warm, give in light, and offer you a place to gather, but they will each make your outdoor space a different feel. Think about the following things to help you choose the choice that fits your style:

1. Romantic and Intimate Ambiance

Outdoor fireplaces often evoke a sense of style and sophistication. This feels cozy and private since it is closed off, making it great for a romantic evening or a quiet conversation. The dancing flames behind the glass panels give the room a touch of luxury while making for an interesting focus point. With an outdoor fireplace, your backyard can become a beautiful place for a date night or to sigh with longing while the stars shine.

Fire pits give off a more natural and laid-back vibe; since they are open, they make for a casual setting like a campfire. The clattering sounds, the sweet smell of burning wood, and the warmth from the open flames make the room feel calm and welcoming. Sit around a fire pit that burns wood and enjoy the simple joys of hot cocoa and marshmallows with family and friends.

2. Flexibility and Customization Options

When it comes to flexibility, fire pits are the best option. Since there are plenty of portable fire pits, they are easy to move around your outdoor area. Due to this, you can change how your outdoor space is set up to suit your needs or even move the fire pit to a different spot. Fire pits also come in various styles, so you can make them look how you want them to.

Outdoor fireplaces, meanwhile, are usually permanent installations. They require more planning and are often part of a bigger building job. This stability can be a good thing if you want a built-in, structured look that fits in well with your outdoor design. With relaxed built-in seating or even a cozy cocktail bar around it, a fireplace can be a beautiful focus point.

Remember that the choice between an outdoor fireplace and a fire pit ultimately comes down to your style, taste, and the mood you want to set in your backyard. Whether you’re picturing a fancy dinner party outside by a fireplace or a casual get-together with friends around a fire pit, both can improve the atmosphere and help you make memories that will last a lifetime.

Choosing between an outdoor fireplace and a fire pit depends on the vibe you want to create in your outdoor space. Perfect for a peaceful get-together under the stars or a nice date night, outdoor fireplaces create a warm and romantic atmosphere. If you want a more laid-back and natural setting, fire pits are perfect for roasting marshmallows and enjoying the simple joys of a campfire. Think about what you like and the mood you want to create, then make a choice that fits your outdoor place and your style.

Fireplace vs. Fire Pit: How Much Flexibility Is Enough?

custom outdoor living space created by a retaining wall contractor and landscape contractor. They can also be found under "concrete contractors near me".

Portable fire pit

When looking at backyard fire features, one important thing to consider is their flexibility. Both fire pits and fireplaces have their benefits when it comes to being portable and easy to customize.


Fire pits are known for being easy to move, which makes them valuable and flexible. You can move your fire pit to different parts of your yard or even take it camping. This gives you the freedom to create a cozy atmosphere anywhere. On the other hand, fireplaces are more fixed structures that need to be carefully planned and put in place. You usually have to build them into your outdoor space, and they’re not as mobile as fire pits.

Customization Options:

There are many ways to make a fire pit your own. You can pick from different sizes, styles, and materials to match the look you want for your outdoor space. Fire pits can also be powered by gas or wood, offering different experiences and ease levels. It’s easy to start, control, and care for a gas-powered fire pit, but a wood-burning fire pit gives you that standard campfire feel. Even though fireplaces aren’t as flexible, you can still make them fit your outdoor style. However, they might not have as many fuel choices as fire pits.

Consider how flexible you must be before choosing between a fire pit and a fireplace. A fire pit might be the best choice to move your fire feature around and make changes more quickly. On the other hand, a fireplace could be the perfect addition to your outdoor area if you want something that will stay there and not be changed much.

Remember that both choices can make the space feel warm and welcoming, so it comes down to personal taste and what your outdoor space needs.

Gas or wood outdoor fire features?

Outdoor Fireplace vs Outdoor Fire Pit: Which One is Right for You? This image showcases a custom outdoor firep it.

There are a few things you should think about before deciding between a gas-powered fire pit or fireplace and a wood-burning one. Each choice has pros and cons, so it’s essential to consider them all before making a choice.

Pros of Gas-Powered Fire Features

1. Convenience: One of the best things about gas-powered fire pits is their ease of use. You can start a clean-burning fire right away with the push of a button or the flip of a switch.

2. Low upkeep: Fire features that use gas don’t need as much upkeep as wood use. You don’t have to take care of getting firewood, cleaning up ashes, or the smoke and sparks of burning wood.

3. Cleanliness: Gas-powered fire features make less ash and smoke, so they are easier to clean up. Because of this, they are an excellent choice for people who want to enjoy a fire without having to clean up.

Cons of Gas-Powered Fire Features

1. Not as accurate: Gas-powered fire features are handy, but they might not have the same charm and realism as a real wood-burning fire. Some people like the sound and smell of wood burning, that can only be accomplished with a real fireplace or fire pit.

2. Dependence on Fuel: Fire features that run on gas need a fuel source, like natural gas or propane. That means you’ll need to keep fuel on hand to keep the fire going. You may also need to hire a qualified gas contractor for installation and maintenance.

Pros of Wood-Burning Fire Features

1. classic Experience: Fire features that burn wood offer a traditional and authentic fire experience. The crackling of the wood, the smell of burning logs, and the dancing flames make the room feel warm and welcoming.

2. Output of Heat: Fires that burn wood tend to release more heat than gas. A wood-burning fireplace might be a better choice if you want a fire feature that will keep you warm on cold nights.

Cons of Wood-Burning Fire Features

1. upkeep: Fire features that burn wood need more upkeep. You’ll need to get firewood, store it, clean the ashes, and ensure enough airflow to keep smoke from building up.

2. Safety Concerns: Fires that use wood can be dangerous, primarily if not appropriately handled. It’s more likely that sparks and flames will fly out, which can be hazardous. Besides that, you must be careful not to get burned or hurt by mistake.

Finally, choosing a gas-powered or wood-burning fire feature relies on your tastes and how you live. Gas-powered options are easier to use and require less upkeep while wood-burning options offer a more traditional feel and more heat. To make an informed choice, consider things like the atmosphere, the maintenance needed, safety concerns, and the installation process.

A fire pit or outdoor fireplace? What’s the Cost Difference?

Custom fire pit installation

Round Fire Pit

Outdoor fireplaces and fire pits can add warmth and atmosphere to a space that makes you want to hang out outside. However, it is essential to consider the costs of these two choices before making a choice.

Initial Investment

Usually, an outdoor fireplace’s original cost is higher than a fire pit’s. A simple fire pit can cost anywhere from $300 to $1,500, while a large, custom-built fire pit can cost $5,000 or more. Outdoor fireplaces, on the other hand, can cost anywhere from $1,500 to $20,000 or even more, based on the style, the materials used, and any extras like seating or cooking grates that are built in. The cost is higher because of the materials used and how hard they are to put, like stone or brick.

Maintenance Expenses

Another thing to think about is the cost of maintenance. Most of the time, fire pits are easy and cheaper to keep up. Usually, the only upkeep needed is cleaning the fire ring or burner regularly and replacing it every so often. On the other hand, outdoor fires might need more care. For the safety and usefulness of an outdoor fireplace, it’s essential to clean the chimney, fix or replace the firebricks, and ensure there is enough airflow. The long-term costs of having an outdoor fireplace may increase because of these extra maintenance jobs.

Overall, fire pits are the more affordable choice regarding the original and upkeep costs. It’s essential to remember that the exact costs will depend on things like the size, materials, and extras you pick.

If you want a safe and effective installation, hire a professional gas contractor like Advanced Pavers & Landscape, whether you choose a cozy fire pit or a beautiful outdoor fireplace. We have many outdoor fire features, like fireplaces and fire pits, and can help you choose the best one for your needs and price during an in-person consultation.

Space Utilization and Installation Requirements

Fire Pit and Paver Patio Landscape Design

Basalite Pavers – Custom paver patio and fire pit outdoor living space

When picturing your perfect outdoor sanctuary, knowing how the space will work and what you’ll need to put it is essential. Because of their grandeur and structural presence, outdoor fireplaces are often the focal point of your landscaping. But they need a lot of room and must be placed in a way that looks good with your outdoor area. The process of installing them is more complicated and must follow building rules. Professional construction work, such as masonry or electrical work for gas-powered units, is often needed. With this feature, they work better in bigger yards where their size doesn’t take up too much room.

On the other hand, fire pits give you more options than any other feature for using your room. Their different shapes and sizes, from built-in models to movable ones, give you more options for where to put them and how to use them. A fire pit can be the center of attention in a large yard. It can look great on a small patio. It’s usually easier to set up a fire pit, making it a good choice for people who want to add something to their outdoor space quickly and with less work. Also, portable fire pits can be an excellent option for homes that don’t have a lot of outdoor space. They give you the luxury of a fire feature without the stability or space needs of a fireplace.

Ultimately, the differences in space on your land and the installation needs of each option should help you decide between a fire pit and an outdoor fireplace. As a landscape designer, I always aim to find a balance between how something looks and how it works. I want to make sure that the fire feature you choose makes your outdoor space look better and works well with your lifestyle and the way your property is laid out.

Are you ready for a fire pit or fireplace outside? You can trust Advanced Pavers & Landscape.

Are you looking for a place to add a cozy fire pit to your backyard in Sacramento, CA, or its surrounding cities? Look no further than Advanced Pavers & Landscape in Sacramento, CA. We know how to help you choose between an outdoor fireplace and a fire pit because they are a trusted design and installation company of outdoor fire features.

Advanced Pavers & Landscape knows how important it is to make your outdoor living area feel warm and inviting. We can help you make your dreams come true, whether you want a cozy meeting around a fire or a fancy dinner party outside.

When you hire us, you can be sure we will care for everything. Advanced Pavers & Landscape has the knowledge and skills to make your backyard magical, from building to ensuring safety rules are followed.

Their skilled designers will work closely with you during an on-site consultation to find the best fire feature choice for your needs and tastes. They will think about things like the size of your yard, the mood you want to create, and any planning issues.

If you choose Advanced Pavers & Landscape, you can be sure that your outdoor fireplace or fire pit will make your room look better and feel warmer and raise the value of your home. With their dedication to quality work and attention to detail, they are sure to go above and beyond what you expect.

Don’t settle for a typical fire pit outside. You can count on Advanced Pavers & Landscape in Sacramento, CA, to add something beautiful and valuable to your outdoor space. Get in touch with them right away to set up a meeting at your home and start turning your backyard into a cozy getaway.

If you want to enjoy a safe and beautiful outdoor fire feature, whether you choose a fire pit or an outdoor fireplace, these topics will help you. Don’t forget to think about safety, set aside time for care, and look for design ideas that fit your style and the space you have outside.

FAQ: Fireplace vs. Fire Pit

1. What is better: a fireplace or a fire pit?

Fireplace: This is a great way to add some architecture to your yard. Gives you more power over and direction over the heat source.
Fire pits are great for getting together with friends and family because they let everyone see what’s happening. It’s usually more relaxed and great for many occasions.

2. What are the disadvantages of a fire pit?

Open to the weather, and you have less control over where the smoke goes.
If not handled properly, it can be dangerous.
It could be less attractive than a stove that is built in.

3. Are outdoor fireplaces worth it?

Yes, if you want to add something fixed that looks good and can raise the value of your home.
It creates a controlled space for fire, with less smoke and a clear path for it to follow.

4. What are the cons of an outdoor fireplace?

Usually cost more and last longer than fire pits.
Because of its shape and smoke direction, it needs more room and a specific placement.

5. Outdoor Fireplace vs. Fire Pit: What’s the Difference?

Structured and controlled, an outdoor fireplace is perfect for small gatherings.
The fire pit is open, relaxed, and a great place for a group to hang out.

6. What are the differences between a fire pit and an outdoor fireplace?

Design and Structure: Fire pits can be put in or taken with you, while fireplaces are usually fixed in place.
Heat Distribution: A fireplace sends heat in one way, but a fire pit spreads it out all over the room.
Style and Use: Fireplaces are more formal, while fire pits are more relaxed.

7. Should I build a fireplace (fire pit) or just buy one into my patio?

Built-in: This option gives a smooth look and might raise the value of your home, but it costs more and lasts longer.
Portable: It’s easier to use, costs less, and can be moved or kept as needed.

8. Which is better, a wood burning or gas fire pit outdoors?

The wood burning gives you a more classic experience and a natural atmosphere with crackling sounds, but it needs more upkeep and firewood.
Gas: It’s easier to keep up, lights instantly and doesn’t make smoke, but it doesn’t have the warm feel of a wood fire and needs a gas line or propane tank.

Learn about our landscape design and installation process in Sacramento, CA, here.
Explore our recommended pavers here.

Advanced Pavers Logo

Subscribe to Our Blog!

Stay updated with the latest tips and tricks on outdoor living space transformation. Subscribe to our blog and never miss a post.


Read the recent articles

Choose The Best For Your Outdoor Spaces

Whether your preference leans towards modern, traditional, Mediterranean, tropical, or cottage landscape design, or you’re interested in a paver patio, we are here to bring your vision to life. We pride ourselves in creating outdoor spaces that exceed your expectations, adding value to your property, and enhancing your quality of life.